Matching Items (6)
Filtering by
- Genre: Masters Thesis
Description
Students' ability to regulate and control their behaviors during learning has been shown to be a critical skill for academic success. However, researchers often struggle with ways to capture the nuances of this ability, often solely relying on self-report measures. This thesis proposal employs a novel approach to investigating variations in students' ability to self-regulate by using process data from the game-based Intelligent Tutoring System (ITS) iSTART-ME. This approach affords a nuanced examination of how students' regulate their interactions with game-based features at both a coarse-grained and fine-grain levels and the ultimate impact that those behaviors have on in-system performance and learning outcomes (i.e., self-explanation quality). This thesis is comprised of two submitted manuscripts that examined how a group of 40 high school students chose to engage with game-based features and how those interactions influenced their target skill performance. Findings suggest that in-system log data has the potential to provide stealth assessments of students' self-regulation while learning.
ContributorsSnow, Erica L (Author) / McNamara, Danielle S. (Thesis advisor) / Glenburg, Arthur M (Committee member) / Duran, Nicholas (Committee member) / Arizona State University (Publisher)
Created2014
Description
Lots of previous studies have analyzed human tutoring at great depths and have shown expert human tutors to produce effect sizes, which is twice of that produced by an intelligent tutoring system (ITS). However, there has been no consensus on which factor makes them so effective. It is important to know this, so that same phenomena can be replicated in an ITS in order to achieve the same level of proficiency as expert human tutors. Also, to the best of my knowledge no one has looked at student reactions when they are working with a computer based tutor. The answers to both these questions are needed in order to build a highly effective computer-based tutor. My research focuses on the second question. In the first phase of my thesis, I analyzed the behavior of students when they were working with a step-based tutor Andes, using verbal-protocol analysis. The accomplishment of doing this was that I got to know of some ways in which students use a step-based tutor which can pave way for the creation of more effective computer-based tutors. I found from the first phase of the research that students often keep trying to fix errors by guessing repeatedly instead of asking for help by clicking the hint button. This phenomenon is known as hint refusal. Surprisingly, a large portion of the student's foundering was due to hint refusal. The hypothesis tested in the second phase of the research is that hint refusal can be significantly reduced and learning can be significantly increased if Andes uses more unsolicited hints and meta hints. An unsolicited hint is a hint that is given without the student asking for one. A meta-hint is like an unsolicited hint in that it is given without the student asking for it, but it just prompts the student to click on the hint button. Two versions of Andes were compared: the original version and a new version that gave more unsolicited and meta-hints. During a two-hour experiment, there were large, statistically reliable differences in several performance measures suggesting that the new policy was more effective.
ContributorsRanganathan, Rajagopalan (Author) / VanLehn, Kurt (Thesis advisor) / Atkinson, Robert (Committee member) / Burleson, Winslow (Committee member) / Arizona State University (Publisher)
Created2011
Description
EMBRACE (Enhanced Moved By Reading to Accelerate Comprehension in English) is an IPad application that uses the Moved By Reading strategy to help improve the reading comprehension skills of bilingual (Spanish speaking) English Language Learners (ELLs). In EMBRACE, students read the text of a story and then move images corresponding to the text that they read. According to the embodied cognition theory, this grounds reading comprehension in physical experiences and thus is more engaging.
In this thesis, I used the log data from 20 students in grades 2-5 to design a skill model for a student using EMBRACE. A skill model is the set of knowledge components that a student needs to master in order to comprehend the text in EMBRACE. A good skill model will improve understanding of the mistakes students make and thus aid in the design of useful feedback for the student.. In this context, the skill model consists of vocabulary and syntax associated with the steps that students performed. I mapped each step in EMBRACE to one or more skills (vocabulary and syntax) from the model. After every step, the skill level is updated in the model. Thus, if a student answered the previous step incorrectly, the corresponding skills are decremented and if the student answered the previous question correctly, the corresponding skills are incremented, through the Bayesian Knowledge Tracing algorithm.
I then correlated the students’ predicted scores (computed from their skill levels) to their posttest scores. I evaluated the students’ predicted scores (computed from their skill levels) by comparing them to their posttest scores. The two sets of scores were not highly correlated, but the results gave insights into potential improvements that could be made to the system with respect to user interaction, posttest scores and modeling algorithm.
In this thesis, I used the log data from 20 students in grades 2-5 to design a skill model for a student using EMBRACE. A skill model is the set of knowledge components that a student needs to master in order to comprehend the text in EMBRACE. A good skill model will improve understanding of the mistakes students make and thus aid in the design of useful feedback for the student.. In this context, the skill model consists of vocabulary and syntax associated with the steps that students performed. I mapped each step in EMBRACE to one or more skills (vocabulary and syntax) from the model. After every step, the skill level is updated in the model. Thus, if a student answered the previous step incorrectly, the corresponding skills are decremented and if the student answered the previous question correctly, the corresponding skills are incremented, through the Bayesian Knowledge Tracing algorithm.
I then correlated the students’ predicted scores (computed from their skill levels) to their posttest scores. I evaluated the students’ predicted scores (computed from their skill levels) by comparing them to their posttest scores. The two sets of scores were not highly correlated, but the results gave insights into potential improvements that could be made to the system with respect to user interaction, posttest scores and modeling algorithm.
ContributorsFurtado, Nicolette Dolores (Author) / Walker, Erin (Thesis advisor) / Hsiao, Ihan (Committee member) / Restrepo, M. Adelaida (Committee member) / Arizona State University (Publisher)
Created2016
Description
Many English Language Learner (ELL) children struggle with knowledge of vocabulary and syntax. Enhanced Moved by Reading to Accelerate Comprehension in English (EMBRACE) is an interactive storybook application that teaches children to read by moving pictures on the screen to act out the sentences in the text. However, EMBRACE presents the same level of text to all users, and it is limited in its ability to provide error feedback, as it can only determine whether a user action is right or wrong. EMBRACE could help readers learn more effectively if it personalized its instruction with texts that fit their current reading level and feedback that addresses ways to correct their mistakes. Improvements were made to the system by applying design principles of intelligent tutoring systems (ITSs). The new system added features to track the student’s reading comprehension skills, including vocabulary, syntax, and usability, based on various user actions, as well as features to adapt text complexity and provide more specific error feedback using the skills. A pilot study was conducted with 7 non-ELL students to evaluate the functionality and effectiveness of these features. The results revealed both strengths and weaknesses of the ITS. While skill updates appeared most accurate when users made particular kinds of vocabulary and syntax errors, it was not able to correctly identify other kinds of syntax errors or provide feedback when skill values became too high. Additionally, vocabulary error feedback and adapting the complexity of syntax were helpful, but syntax error feedback and adapting the complexity of vocabulary were not as helpful. Overall, children enjoy using EMBRACE, and building an intelligent tutoring system into the application presents a promising approach to make reading a both fun and effective experience.
ContributorsWong, Audrey (Author) / Walker, Erin (Thesis advisor) / Nelson, Brian (Committee member) / Glenberg, Arthur (Committee member) / Arizona State University (Publisher)
Created2017
Description
Feedback represents a vital component of the learning process and is especially important for Computer Science students. With class sizes that are often large, it can be challenging to provide individualized feedback to students. Consistent, constructive, supportive feedback through a tutoring companion can scaffold the learning process for students.
This work contributes to the construction of a tutoring companion designed to provide this feedback to students. It aims to bridge the gap between the messages the compiler delivers, and the support required for a novice student to understand the problem and fix their code. Particularly, it provides support for students learning about recursion in a beginning university Java programming course. Besides also providing affective support, a tutoring companion could be more effective when it is embedded into the environment that the student is already using, instead of an additional tool for the student to learn. The proposed Tutoring Companion is embedded into the Eclipse Integrated Development Environment (IDE).
This thesis focuses on the reasoning model for the Tutoring Companion and is developed using the techniques of a neural network. While a student uses the IDE, the Tutoring Companion collects 16 data points, including the presence of certain key words, cyclomatic complexity, and error messages from the compiler, every time it detects an event, such as a run attempt, debug attempt, or a request for help, in the IDE. This data is used as inputs to the neural network. The neural network produces a correlating single output code for the feedback to be provided to the student, which is displayed in the IDE.
The effectiveness of the approach is examined among 38 Computer Science students who solve a programming assignment while the Tutoring Companion assists them. Data is collected from these interactions, including all inputs and outputs for the neural network, and students are surveyed regarding their experience. Results suggest that students feel supported while working with the Companion and promising potential for using a neural network with an embedded companion in the future. Challenges in developing an embedded companion are discussed, as well as opportunities for future work.
This work contributes to the construction of a tutoring companion designed to provide this feedback to students. It aims to bridge the gap between the messages the compiler delivers, and the support required for a novice student to understand the problem and fix their code. Particularly, it provides support for students learning about recursion in a beginning university Java programming course. Besides also providing affective support, a tutoring companion could be more effective when it is embedded into the environment that the student is already using, instead of an additional tool for the student to learn. The proposed Tutoring Companion is embedded into the Eclipse Integrated Development Environment (IDE).
This thesis focuses on the reasoning model for the Tutoring Companion and is developed using the techniques of a neural network. While a student uses the IDE, the Tutoring Companion collects 16 data points, including the presence of certain key words, cyclomatic complexity, and error messages from the compiler, every time it detects an event, such as a run attempt, debug attempt, or a request for help, in the IDE. This data is used as inputs to the neural network. The neural network produces a correlating single output code for the feedback to be provided to the student, which is displayed in the IDE.
The effectiveness of the approach is examined among 38 Computer Science students who solve a programming assignment while the Tutoring Companion assists them. Data is collected from these interactions, including all inputs and outputs for the neural network, and students are surveyed regarding their experience. Results suggest that students feel supported while working with the Companion and promising potential for using a neural network with an embedded companion in the future. Challenges in developing an embedded companion are discussed, as well as opportunities for future work.
ContributorsDay, Melissa (Author) / Gonzalez-Sanchez, Javier (Thesis advisor) / Bansal, Ajay (Committee member) / Mehlhase, Alexandra (Committee member) / Arizona State University (Publisher)
Created2019
Description
Embedded assessment constantly updates a model of the student as the student works on instructional tasks. Accurate embedded assessment allows students, instructors and instructional systems to make informed decisions without requiring the student to stop instruction and take a test. This thesis describes the development and comparison of several student models for Dragoon, an intelligent tutoring system. All the models were instances of Bayesian Knowledge Tracing, a standard method. Several methods of parameterization and calibration were explored using two recently developed toolkits, FAST and BNT-SM that replaces constant-valued parameters with logistic regressions. The evaluation was done by calculating the fit of the models to data from human subjects and by assessing the accuracy of their assessment of simulated students. The student models created using node properties as subskills were superior to coarse-grained, skill-only models. Adding this extra level of representation to emission parameters was superior to adding it to transmission parameters. Adding difficulty parameters did not improve fit, contrary to standard practice in psychometrics.
ContributorsGrover, Sachin (Author) / VanLehn, Kurt (Thesis advisor) / Walker, Erin (Committee member) / Shiao, Ihan (Committee member) / Arizona State University (Publisher)
Created2015