Matching Items (10)
Description
To address sustainability issues in wastewater treatment (WWT), Siemens Water Technologies (SWT) has designed a "hybrid" process that couples common activated sludge (AS) and anaerobic digestion (AD) technologies with the novel concepts of AD sludge recycle and biosorption. At least 85% of the hybrid's AD sludge is recycled to the AS process, providing additional sorbent for influent particulate chemical oxygen demand (PCOD) biosorption in contact tanks. Biosorbed PCOD is transported to the AD, where it is converted to methane. The aim of this study is to provide mass balance and microbial community analysis (MCA) of SWT's two hybrid and one conventional pilot plant trains and mathematical modeling of the hybrid process including a novel model of biosorption. A detailed mass balance was performed on each tank and the overall system. The mass balance data supports the hybrid process is more sustainable: It produces 1.5 to 5.5x more methane and 50 to 83% less sludge than the conventional train. The hybrid's superior performance is driven by 4 to 8 times longer solid retention times (SRTs) as compared to conventional trains. However, the conversion of influent COD to methane was low at 15 to 22%, and neither train exhibited significant nitrification or denitrification. Data were inconclusive as to the role of biosorption in the processes. MCA indicated the presence of Archaea and nitrifiers throughout both systems. However, it is inconclusive as to how active Archaea and nitrifiers are under anoxic, aerobic, and anaerobic conditions. Mathematical modeling confirms the hybrid process produces 4 to 20 times more methane and 20 to 83% less sludge than the conventional train under various operating conditions. Neither process removes more than 25% of the influent nitrogen or converts more that 13% to nitrogen gas due to biomass washout in the contact tank and short SRTs in the stabilization tank. In addition, a mathematical relationship was developed to describe PCOD biosorption through adsorption to biomass and floc entrapment. Ultimately, process performance is more heavily influenced by the higher AD SRTs attained when sludge is recycled through the system and less influenced by the inclusion of biosorption kinetics.
ContributorsYoung, Michelle Nichole (Author) / Rittmann, Bruce E. (Thesis advisor) / Fox, Peter (Committee member) / Krajmalnik-Brown, Rosa (Committee member) / Arizona State University (Publisher)
Created2011
Description
Microbial electrochemical cells (MxCs) are a novel technology that use anode-respiring bacteria (ARB) to bioremediate wastewaters and respire an electrical current, which can then be used directly to produce value-added products like hydrogen peroxide (H2O2). Ninety-five percent of the world’s H2O2 is currently produced using the anthraquinone process, whose production requires expensive and potentially carcinogenic catalysts and high amounts of electricity. However, the amount of H2O2 that can be produced from these microbial peroxide-producing cells (MPPCs) has not been thoroughly investigated. Predicting potential H2O2 production in MxCs is further complicated by a lack of mathematical models to predict performance utilizing complex waste streams like primary sludge (PS).
A reactor design methodology was developed for MPPCs to systematically optimize H2O2 production with minimal energy consumption. H2O2 stability was evaluated with different catholytes, membranes, and catalysts materials, and the findings used to design and operate long-term a dual-chamber, flat-plate MPPC using different catholytes, ferrochelating stabilizers, and hydraulic retention times (HRT). Up to 3.1 ± 0.37 g H2O2 L-1 was produced at a 4-h HRT in an MPPC with as little as 1.13 W-h g-1 H2O2 power input using NaCl catholytes. Attempts to improve H2O2 production by using weak acid buffers as catholytes or ferrochelating stabilizers failed for different reasons.
A non-steady-state mathematical model, MYAnode, was developed combinging existing wastewater treatment, anode biofilm, and chemical speciation models to predict MxC performance utilizing complex substrates. The model simulated the large-scale trends observed when operating an MPPC with PS substrate. At HRTs ≥ 12-d, the model demonstrated up to 20% Coulombic recovery. At these conditions, ARB required additional alkalinity production by ≥ 100 mgVSS/L of acetoclastic methanogens to prevent pH inhibition when little influent alkalinity is available. At lower HRTs, methanogens are unable to produce the alkalinity required to prevent ARB inhibition due to washout and rapid acidification of the system during fermentation. At ≥ 100 mgVSS/L of methanogens, increasing the diffusion layer thickness from 500 to 1000 μm improved Coulombic efficiency by 13.9%, while increasing particulate COD hydrolysis rates to 0.25/d only improved Coulombic efficiency by 3.9%.
A reactor design methodology was developed for MPPCs to systematically optimize H2O2 production with minimal energy consumption. H2O2 stability was evaluated with different catholytes, membranes, and catalysts materials, and the findings used to design and operate long-term a dual-chamber, flat-plate MPPC using different catholytes, ferrochelating stabilizers, and hydraulic retention times (HRT). Up to 3.1 ± 0.37 g H2O2 L-1 was produced at a 4-h HRT in an MPPC with as little as 1.13 W-h g-1 H2O2 power input using NaCl catholytes. Attempts to improve H2O2 production by using weak acid buffers as catholytes or ferrochelating stabilizers failed for different reasons.
A non-steady-state mathematical model, MYAnode, was developed combinging existing wastewater treatment, anode biofilm, and chemical speciation models to predict MxC performance utilizing complex substrates. The model simulated the large-scale trends observed when operating an MPPC with PS substrate. At HRTs ≥ 12-d, the model demonstrated up to 20% Coulombic recovery. At these conditions, ARB required additional alkalinity production by ≥ 100 mgVSS/L of acetoclastic methanogens to prevent pH inhibition when little influent alkalinity is available. At lower HRTs, methanogens are unable to produce the alkalinity required to prevent ARB inhibition due to washout and rapid acidification of the system during fermentation. At ≥ 100 mgVSS/L of methanogens, increasing the diffusion layer thickness from 500 to 1000 μm improved Coulombic efficiency by 13.9%, while increasing particulate COD hydrolysis rates to 0.25/d only improved Coulombic efficiency by 3.9%.
ContributorsYoung, Michelle Nichole (Author) / Rittmann, Bruce E. (Thesis advisor) / Torres, César I (Committee member) / Marcus, Andrew K (Committee member) / Arizona State University (Publisher)
Created2018
Description
Microbial fuel cells (MFCs) promote the sustainable conversion of organic matter in black water to electrical current, enabling the production of hydrogen peroxide (H2O2) while making waste water treatment energy neutral or positive. H2O2 is useful in remote locations such as U.S. military forward operating bases (FOBs) for on-site tertiary water treatment or as a medical disinfectant, among many other uses. Various carbon-based catalysts and binders for use at the cathode of a an MFC for H2O2 production are explored using linear sweep voltammetry (LSV) and rotating ring-disk electrode (RRDE) techniques. The oxygen reduction reaction (ORR) at the cathode has slow kinetics at conditions present in the MFC, making it important to find a catalyst type and loading which promote a 2e- (rather than 4e-) reaction to maximize H2O2 formation. Using LSV methods, I compared the cathodic overpotentials associated with graphite and Vulcan carbon catalysts as well as Nafion and AS-4 binders. Vulcan carbon catalyst with Nafion binder produced the lowest overpotentials of any binder/catalyst combinations. Additionally, I determined that pH control may be required at the cathode due to large potential losses caused by hydroxide (OH-) concentration gradients. Furthermore, RRDE tests indicate that Vulcan carbon catalyst with a Nafion binder has a higher H2O2 production efficiency at lower catalyst loadings, but the trade-off is a greater potential loss due to higher activation energy. Therefore, an intermediate catalyst loading of 0.5 mg/cm2 Vulcan carbon with Nafion binder is recommended for the final MFC design. The chosen catalyst, binder, and loading will maximize H2O2 production, optimize MFC performance, and minimize the need for additional energy input into the system.
ContributorsStadie, Mikaela Johanna (Author) / Torres, Cesar (Thesis director) / Popat, Sudeep (Committee member) / Barrett, The Honors College (Contributor) / Chemical Engineering Program (Contributor)
Created2015-05
Description
Six high-production-volume neonicotinoids were traced through a municipal wastewater treatment plant (WWTP) and engineered wetland located downstream, in a study motivated by reports on these insecticides posing threats to non-target invertebrate species and potentially playing a role in the global honeybee colony collapse disorder. An array of automated samplers was deployed in a five-day monitoring campaign and resultant flow-weighted samples were analyzed by liquid chromatography tandem mass spectrometry (LC-MS/MS) using the isotope dilution method. Concentrations in WWTP influent and effluent were 54.7 ± 2.9 and 48.6 ± 2.7 ng/L for imidacloprid, respectively, and 3.7 ± 0.3 and 1.8 ± 0.1 ng/L for acetamiprid, respectively. A mass balance over the WWTP showed no (p=0.09, CI = 95%) removal of imidacloprid, and 56 ± 6% aqueous removal of acetamiprid. In the constructed wetland downstream, a lack of removal was noted for both imidacloprid (from 54.4 ± 3.4 ng/L to 49.9 ± 14.6 ng/L) and acetamiprid (from 2.00 ± 0.03 ng/L to 2.30 ± 0.21 ng/L). Clothianidin was detected only inconsistently in the WWTP and wetland (>2 to 288 ng/L; 60% detection frequency), whereas thiamethoxam (<10 ng/L), thiacloprid (<2 ng/L), and dinotefuran (<180 ng/L) were not detected at all. Thus, imidacloprid and acetamiprid were identified as recalcitrant sewage constituents (estimated U.S. WWTP discharge of 1920- 4780 kg/y) that persist during conventional wastewater treatment to enter U.S. surface waters at potentially harmful concentrations.
ContributorsSadaria, Akash Mahendra (Author) / Halden, Rolf (Thesis advisor) / Fox, Peter (Committee member) / Popat, Sudeep (Committee member) / Arizona State University (Publisher)
Created2015
Description
City managers and policy makers are increasing looking to environmental systems to provide beneficial services for urban systems. Constructed wetland systems (CWS), highly managed and designed wetland ecosystems, are being utilized to remove pollution, particularly excess nitrogen (N), from treated wastewater. Various wetland process remove N from effluent, such as denitrification, direct plant uptake, and soil accumulation. Emergent macrophytes provide direct uptake of N and improve conditions for microbially-mediated N processing. The role of different macrophytes species, however, is less understood and has primarily been examined in mesocosm and microcosm experiments and in mesic environments. I examined the effects of community composition on N removal and processing at the whole ecosystem scale in an aridland, constructed wetland (42 ha) through: 1) quantifying above- and belowground biomass and community composition from July 2011 \u2014 November 2012 using a non-destructive allometric technique, and; 2) quantifying macrophyte N content and direct macrophyte N uptake over the 2012 growing season. Average peak biomass in July 2011 & 2012 was 2,930 g dw/m2 and 2,340 g dw/m2, respectively. Typha spp. (Typha domingensis and Typha latifolia) comprised the majority (approximately 2/3) of live aboveground biomass throughout the sampling period. No statistically significant differences were observed in macrophyte N content among the six species present, with an overall average of 1.68% N in aboveground tissues and 1.29% N in belowground tissues. Per unit area of wetland, Typha spp. retained the most N (22 g/m2); total N retained by all species was 34 g/m2. System-wide direct plant N uptake was markedly lower than N input to the system and thus represented a small portion of system N processing. Soil accumulation of N also played a minor role, leaving denitrification as the likely process responsible for the majority of system N processing. Based on a literature review, macrophyte species composition likely influences denitrification through oxygen diffusion into soils and through the quality and quantity of carbon in leaf litter. While this study and the literature indicates Typha spp. may be the best species to promote wetland N processing, other considerations (e.g., bird habitat) and conditions (e.g., type of wastewater being treated) likely make mixed stands of macrophytes preferable in many applications. Additionally, this study demonstrated the importance of urban wetlands as scientific laboratories for scientists of all ages and as excellent stepping-off points for experiments of science-policy discourse.
ContributorsWeller, Nicholas Anton (Author) / Daniel L., Childers (Thesis director) / Grimm, Nancy (Committee member) / Turnbull, Laura (Committee member) / Barrett, The Honors College (Contributor) / School of Sustainability (Contributor) / School of Public Affairs (Contributor) / Graduate College (Contributor)
Created2013-05
Description
Duckponics is an unconventional form of aquaponics that has recently been implemented by a small community in Washington State as an experiment in sustainable methods of food production. The community created the Duckponics system to test the possibility of using the waste of ducks present on the farm to fertilize crop plants. This research paper examines aspects of the nitrogen cycle within this system to determine the efficacy of nitrogen removal by plants and microbes. More specifically, the research examines (1) the microbial activity occurring in selected beds of the system, (2) the ability of hydroponic grow beds to retain inorganic nitrogen, and (3) how periodic flushing of the system affects nitrogen retention. Water data was collected in all system tanks using aquarium test strips, but water samples were collected for flow injection analysis in (1) one of the grow beds, (2) the duck pond, and (3) a control bed with no plants but filled with gravel and inoculated with the same bacteria from the grow bed. Samples were then analyzed for ammonia (NH4+-N) and combined nitrite and nitrate (NOx-N) concentrations. The results show that the treatment type (control, duck pond, or grow bed) was a significant (p<0.05) predictor of NH4+-N, NOx-N, and total inorganic nitrogen (TIN) in the porewater of the treatment beds. The grow bed was found to have 100% removal of TIN, whereas the control had 0% TIN removal (195% increase). Timing of the sample in relation to the flushing events was a moderately significant predictor of TIN, NH4+-N and NOx-N in the duck pond (p = 0.07 for TIN, p = 0.12 for NH4+-N, p = 0.11 for NOx-N), with an overall decrease in TIN after flood pulses. NH4+-N concentrations at the inlet and outlet were found to be significantly different in the grow bed (p=0.037), but not the control, and moderately significantly different (p<0.15) for NOx-N and TIN in the grow bed (p=0.072 for NOx-N, p=0.075 for TIN), but significant for the control (p=0.043). These findings show evidence of nitrification in the grow bed and control, plant presence significantly contributing to nitrogen removal in the grow bed, and some hydrologic flushing of NOx-N out of the duck pond during pump cycles.
ContributorsPanfil, Daniela Kristiina (Author) / Doucette, Sonya (Thesis director) / Palta, Monica (Committee member) / Moody, Jack (Committee member) / Civil, Environmental and Sustainable Engineering Programs (Contributor) / School of Sustainability (Contributor) / W. P. Carey School of Business (Contributor) / Barrett, The Honors College (Contributor)
Created2016-05
Description
The waterways in the United States are polluted by agricultural, mining, and industrial activities. Recovery of valuable materials, such as energy and nutrients, from these waste streams can improve the economic and environmental sustainability of wastewater treatment. A number of state-of-the-art anaerobic bioreactors have promise for intensified anaerobic biological treatment and energy recovery, but they have drawbacks. The drawbacks should be overcome with a novel anaerobic biological wastewater treatment process: the anaerobic biofilm membrane bioreactor (AnBfMBR). This research works aims to advance key components of the AnBfMBR. The AnBfMBR is a hybrid suspended growth and biofilm reactor. The two main components of an AnBfMBR are plastic biofilm carriers and membranes. The plastic biofilm carriers provide the surface onto which the biofilms grow. Membranes provide liquid-solid separation, retention of suspended biomass, and a solids-free effluent. Introducing sufficient surface area promotes the biofilm accumulation of slow-growing methanogens that convert volatile fatty acids into methane gas. Biofilms growing on these surfaces will have a mixed culture that primarily consists of methanogens and inert particulate solids, but also includes some acetogens. Biomass that detaches from biofilms become a component of the suspended growth. A bench-scale AnBfMBR was designed by the AnBfMBR project team and constructed by SafBon Water Technology (SWT). The primary objective of this thesis project was to evaluate the ability of plastic biofilm carriers to minimize ceramic-membrane fouling in the AnBfMBR setting. A systematic analysis of mixing for the bench-scale AnBfMBR was also conducted with the plastic biofilm carriers. Experiments were conducted following a ‘run to failure’ method, in which the ceramic membranes provide filtration, and the time it takes to reach a ‘failure transmembrane pressure (TMP)’ was recorded. The experiments revealed two distinct trends. First, the time to failure TMP decreased as mixed liquor suspended solids concentration (MLSS) concentration increased. Second, increasing the carrier fill extend the time to failure, particularly for higher MLSS concentrations. Taken together, the experiments identified an optimized “sweet spot” for the AnBfMBR: an operating flux of 0.25-m/d, a failure TMP of 0.3-atm pressure, MLSS of 5,000 – 7,500 mg/L, and 40% carrier fill.
ContributorsRoman, Brian Aaron (Author) / Rittmann, Bruce (Thesis advisor) / Boltz, Joshua (Committee member) / Perreault, Francois (Committee member) / Fox, Peter (Committee member) / Arizona State University (Publisher)
Created2021
Description
This dissertation studies the larger issue of antibiotic resistance with respect to how antibiotics are being introduced into the environment, focusing on two major anthropogenic pathways: animal husbandry for human consumption, and the recycling of wastewater and municipal sludge generated during conventional biological sewage treatment.
For animal production on land (agriculture) antibiotics are often used for growth enhancement and increased feed efficiency. For animal production in water (aquaculture) antibiotics are often used as a prophylactic. I found that the same antibiotics are being used in both industries and that the same strains of human pathogens have also been isolated from both sources, expressing identical resistance mechanisms. In U.S. seafood, five out of 47 antibiotics screened for were detected at levels of 0.3 to 7.7 ng/g fresh weight. Although compliant with FDA regulations, the risk for resistance still exists, as even low antibiotic concentrations have been shown to exert selective pressure on bacteria.
Similarly low concentrations of antibiotics were found in U.S. biosolids at levels of 0.6 to 19.1 ng/g dry weight. Of the five antibiotics detected, two have never been reported before in biosolids. Three have never been reported before in U.S. biosolids. Using the raw numbers obtained from antibiotic screenings in biosolids, I assessed the impact of employing four different LC-MS/MS methods, concluding that analysts should experimentally determine the most appropriate quantitation method based on the analyte targeted, matrix investigated, and research goals pursued. Preferred quantitation approaches included the isotope dilution method with use of an analogous standard and, although time and resource demanding, the method of standard addition.
In conclusion, antibiotics introduced into the environment via agriculture, aquaculture, and wastewater recycling pose a combination of chemical and biological threats. Aside from exerting outright chemical toxicity to non-target organisms, antibiotic residues can promote the development of multi-drug resistance in human pathogens. Public health protection approaches to stem the risks posed by animal husbandry may include reserving drugs for exclusive, human use, decreasing their usage altogether, improving reporting efforts, reevaluating existing regulations on agricultural and aquacultural antibiotic usage, and improved risk assessment for biosolids application on land.
For animal production on land (agriculture) antibiotics are often used for growth enhancement and increased feed efficiency. For animal production in water (aquaculture) antibiotics are often used as a prophylactic. I found that the same antibiotics are being used in both industries and that the same strains of human pathogens have also been isolated from both sources, expressing identical resistance mechanisms. In U.S. seafood, five out of 47 antibiotics screened for were detected at levels of 0.3 to 7.7 ng/g fresh weight. Although compliant with FDA regulations, the risk for resistance still exists, as even low antibiotic concentrations have been shown to exert selective pressure on bacteria.
Similarly low concentrations of antibiotics were found in U.S. biosolids at levels of 0.6 to 19.1 ng/g dry weight. Of the five antibiotics detected, two have never been reported before in biosolids. Three have never been reported before in U.S. biosolids. Using the raw numbers obtained from antibiotic screenings in biosolids, I assessed the impact of employing four different LC-MS/MS methods, concluding that analysts should experimentally determine the most appropriate quantitation method based on the analyte targeted, matrix investigated, and research goals pursued. Preferred quantitation approaches included the isotope dilution method with use of an analogous standard and, although time and resource demanding, the method of standard addition.
In conclusion, antibiotics introduced into the environment via agriculture, aquaculture, and wastewater recycling pose a combination of chemical and biological threats. Aside from exerting outright chemical toxicity to non-target organisms, antibiotic residues can promote the development of multi-drug resistance in human pathogens. Public health protection approaches to stem the risks posed by animal husbandry may include reserving drugs for exclusive, human use, decreasing their usage altogether, improving reporting efforts, reevaluating existing regulations on agricultural and aquacultural antibiotic usage, and improved risk assessment for biosolids application on land.
ContributorsDone, Hansa Yi-Yun (Author) / Halden, Rolf U. (Thesis advisor) / Haydel, Shelley E (Committee member) / Abbaszadegan, Morteza (Committee member) / Arizona State University (Publisher)
Created2015
Description
Wastewater treatment plant (WWTP) utilization of combined heat and power (CHP) systems allows for the efficient use of on-site biogas production, as well as increased annual savings in utility costs. In this thesis, a literature review of six CHP prime mover technologies is presented. Even though there are different prime mover technologies, the main ones currently being implemented in WWTPs are micro turbines, fuel cells and reciprocating engines. These prime mover technologies offer varying efficiencies, installation costs and maintenance requirements. The prime movers are also all in different stages of development, leading some to be more currently-in-use than others in WWTPs. Currently reciprocating engines and micro turbines occupy the largest shares of the CHP in WWTP sector.
This thesis will also go in detail into equations and calculations created for a techno-economic assessment for installation and maintenance of a CHP system at a WWTP. The equations and calculations created here were then utilized with data from a typical WWTP in the Southwestern United States to create an accurate case study. In this case study, a payback of 5.7 years and a net present value of $709,000 can be achieved when the WWTP generates over 2,000,000 m3 of biogas per year and utilizes over 36,000 GJ of natural gas per year.
This thesis will also go in detail into equations and calculations created for a techno-economic assessment for installation and maintenance of a CHP system at a WWTP. The equations and calculations created here were then utilized with data from a typical WWTP in the Southwestern United States to create an accurate case study. In this case study, a payback of 5.7 years and a net present value of $709,000 can be achieved when the WWTP generates over 2,000,000 m3 of biogas per year and utilizes over 36,000 GJ of natural gas per year.
ContributorsRiley, Derall (Author) / Milcarek, Ryan (Thesis director) / Villalobos, Rene (Committee member) / Mechanical and Aerospace Engineering Program (Contributor) / Barrett, The Honors College (Contributor)
Created2020-12
Description
Water is a scarce resource that is recycled through wastewater treatment plants (WWTPs) to help fulfill the demand for water. Agriculture is a large consumer of water, indicating that WWTP-treated water is proportionally applied to crops at a high rate. Recycled water is highly regulated but is capable of containing high-risk pathogens and contaminants despite the efforts of physical and microbial treatments throughout the WWTP process. WWTPs are also producers of biosolids, treated sewage sludge regulated by the EPA that can be applied in agricultural settings to act as a fertilizer. Biosolids are a useful fertilizer as they are rich in nitrogen and contain many beneficial nutrients for soil and crops. Due to biosolids being a by-product of recycled water, they are susceptible to containing the same pathogens and contaminants that can be transferred in the WWTP systems. Antibiotic resistance (AR) is an ever-growing threat on a global scale and is one of the areas of concern for consideration of pathogen spread from WWTPs. Antibiotic resistance bacteria, created through mutation of bacterial plasmids producing antibiotic resistance genes (ARGs), have been quantified and studied to help mitigate the risk posed by continued AR spread in the environment. This study aims to produce a comprehensive collection of quantified ARG concentration data in biosolids, as well as producing a QMRA model integrating Monte Carlo distributions to provide groundwork for understanding of the direct dosage and consumption of ARGs to the standard U.S. citizen. The study determined that sul1, sul2, tetM, and tetO are ARGs of high concern in biosolid samples based on current concentration data of biosolid samples. The resulting dose models and gene concentration distributions provide data to support the need to mitigate AR risk presented by agricultural biosolid application.
ContributorsMorgan, Grace (Author) / Hamilton, Kerry (Thesis director) / Muenich, Rebecca (Committee member) / Barrett, The Honors College (Contributor) / Harrington Bioengineering Program (Contributor)
Created2022-05