Matching Items (2)
Filtering by
- All Subjects: philosophy
- Genre: Doctoral Dissertation
- Creators: Lussier, Mark
Description
Situated within seminal debates on the questions of liberation and justice viewed from the postcolonial context, this dissertation evaluates freedom narratives from both sides of the colonial divide during the period of high imperialism. Creating a transnational grouping of three diverse historical figures, E. M. Forster, M. K. Gandhi, and James Joyce, I argue for similarities in these writers’ narrative construction of “freedom” against colonial modernity. I argue that despite these writers’ widely disparate historical and cultural determinations, which uniquely particularize each of their freedom formulas as well as freedom “ideals” – the ideal of culture for Forster, renunciation for Gandhi and aesthetic apprehension for Joyce, these writers conceive of a commensurate/globally related form of “freedom” as postcoloniality and demonstrate cosmopolitan ambition. I also argue that the global form of postcoloniality they each practice can only be articulated through a close attention to each of their specific and local difference.
The key contribution of the dissertation is to establish a new significance of the notion of fetishism for postcolonial studies, from both historical and theoretical perspectives. From a background that emphasizes the primacy of the concept of fetishism in its historical evolution within colonizing narratives of various Western discourses, especially fetish’s constitutive role in Enlightenment philosophy’s othering narrative of “primitive” natives, the work foregrounds a novel theoretical and narrative insight that the fetish demonstrates a unique potential to articulate/embody freedom as post-coloniality. Through a detailed critical analysis of each freedom narrative, I demonstrate how the clashes of particular contradictory cultural ideologies, in fact, determine each freedom narrative and how these contradictions are projected onto and galvanized by a fetish object(s). The work extends the ideas of Sigmund Freud, William Pietz, Homi Bhabha, Anne McClintock and Jacques Derrida on fetishism. Employing the framework of fetishism it brings into view similarities among the said three writers’ definition and practice of freedom. The work weighs in on critical debates between Marxist and Post-structural camps in postcolonial studies and proposes a new form of cosmopolitanism.
The key contribution of the dissertation is to establish a new significance of the notion of fetishism for postcolonial studies, from both historical and theoretical perspectives. From a background that emphasizes the primacy of the concept of fetishism in its historical evolution within colonizing narratives of various Western discourses, especially fetish’s constitutive role in Enlightenment philosophy’s othering narrative of “primitive” natives, the work foregrounds a novel theoretical and narrative insight that the fetish demonstrates a unique potential to articulate/embody freedom as post-coloniality. Through a detailed critical analysis of each freedom narrative, I demonstrate how the clashes of particular contradictory cultural ideologies, in fact, determine each freedom narrative and how these contradictions are projected onto and galvanized by a fetish object(s). The work extends the ideas of Sigmund Freud, William Pietz, Homi Bhabha, Anne McClintock and Jacques Derrida on fetishism. Employing the framework of fetishism it brings into view similarities among the said three writers’ definition and practice of freedom. The work weighs in on critical debates between Marxist and Post-structural camps in postcolonial studies and proposes a new form of cosmopolitanism.
ContributorsMehta, Bina P (Author) / Bivona, Daniel (Thesis advisor) / Codell, Julie (Committee member) / Lussier, Mark (Committee member) / Mallot, Jr., Jack (Committee member) / Arizona State University (Publisher)
Created2017
Description
Selected Poets’ Lived Experience of the Seventh Avenue Streetscape Project: A Phenomenological Study of Meaning and Essence addresses a specific public art project. Public art has a long history of eluding a definition of consensus, and it continues to do so. There is very little in the way of accountability for its effect, and most of what is available is anecdotal. The Seventh Avenue Streetscape (SAS) is no exception in that no follow-ups were ever asked of the community, even though the Melrose Neighborhood District has been revitalized and rescued from its decline with the inception of SAS. It brought residents and business owners together in coordination with the City of Phoenix and Arizona State University to create the unique infrastructure of SAS that presents itself as a sheltered bus stop/outdoor gallery displaying art and poetry on large platform panels to the delight of the citizenry. The purpose of this study was to explore, describe, and interpret the meaning given to the Seventh Avenue Streetscape by poets who participated in that project. The central question guiding the research was “What is the essential meaning and understanding of the lived experience given by poets who participated in the Seventh Avenue Streetscape project and its creation?”
The study was conducted through the qualitative research tradition, guided specifically by the theoretical base known as phenomenology. Phenomenology lends itself particularly well to the study of phenomena such as SAS as its focus is finding the essential in the “everyday” through the expression of lived experience. My primary data source were the poets themselves, those whose poems had been selected to be publicly presented. Once cleared by the Institutional Review Board, my method of data collection involved one-on-one recorded interviews. The interviews were then transcribed and subjected to various methods of data reduction, including coding and themeing the data from the thick description given by the poet-participants. The data revealed patterns among the poets which could be divided into six essential themes, confirming a plausible description and interpretation of SAS. Recommendations included conducting the same study again with the remaining qualifying SAS poets and comparing the results.
ContributorsLanier, Nadine Lynn (Author) / Maring, Heather (Thesis advisor) / de la Garza, Sarah Amira (Committee member) / Lussier, Mark (Committee member) / Arizona State University (Publisher)
Created2023