Matching Items (3)
Description
A Pairwise Comparison Matrix (PCM) is used to compute for relative priorities of criteria or alternatives and are integral components of widely applied decision making tools: the Analytic Hierarchy Process (AHP) and its generalized form, the Analytic Network Process (ANP). However, a PCM suffers from several issues limiting its application to large-scale decision problems, specifically: (1) to the curse of dimensionality, that is, a large number of pairwise comparisons need to be elicited from a decision maker (DM), (2) inconsistent and (3) imprecise preferences maybe obtained due to the limited cognitive power of DMs. This dissertation proposes a PCM Framework for Large-Scale Decisions to address these limitations in three phases as follows. The first phase proposes a binary integer program (BIP) to intelligently decompose a PCM into several mutually exclusive subsets using interdependence scores. As a result, the number of pairwise comparisons is reduced and the consistency of the PCM is improved. Since the subsets are disjoint, the most independent pivot element is identified to connect all subsets. This is done to derive the global weights of the elements from the original PCM. The proposed BIP is applied to both AHP and ANP methodologies. However, it is noted that the optimal number of subsets is provided subjectively by the DM and hence is subject to biases and judgement errors. The second phase proposes a trade-off PCM decomposition methodology to decompose a PCM into a number of optimally identified subsets. A BIP is proposed to balance the: (1) time savings by reducing pairwise comparisons, the level of PCM inconsistency, and (2) the accuracy of the weights. The proposed methodology is applied to the AHP to demonstrate its advantages and is compared to established methodologies. In the third phase, a beta distribution is proposed to generalize a wide variety of imprecise pairwise comparison distributions via a method of moments methodology. A Non-Linear Programming model is then developed that calculates PCM element weights which maximizes the preferences of the DM as well as minimizes the inconsistency simultaneously. Comparison experiments are conducted using datasets collected from literature to validate the proposed methodology.
ContributorsJalao, Eugene Rex Lazaro (Author) / Shunk, Dan L. (Thesis advisor) / Wu, Teresa (Thesis advisor) / Askin, Ronald G. (Committee member) / Goul, Kenneth M (Committee member) / Arizona State University (Publisher)
Created2013
Description
This research by studies the computational performance of four different mixed integer programming (MIP) formulations for single machine scheduling problems with varying complexity. These formulations are based on (1) start and completion time variables, (2) time index variables, (3) linear ordering variables and (4) assignment and positional date variables. The objective functions that are studied in this paper are total weighted completion time, maximum lateness, number of tardy jobs and total weighted tardiness. Based on the computational results, discussion and recommendations are made on which MIP formulation might work best for these problems. The performances of these formulations very much depend on the objective function, number of jobs and the sum of the processing times of all the jobs. Two sets of inequalities are presented that can be used to improve the performance of the formulation with assignment and positional date variables. Further, this research is extend to single machine bicriteria scheduling problems in which jobs belong to either of two different disjoint sets, each set having its own performance measure. These problems have been referred to as interfering job sets in the scheduling literature and also been called multi-agent scheduling where each agent's objective function is to be minimized. In the first single machine interfering problem (P1), the criteria of minimizing total completion time and number of tardy jobs for the two sets of jobs is studied. A Forward SPT-EDD heuristic is presented that attempts to generate set of non-dominated solutions. The complexity of this specific problem is NP-hard. The computational efficiency of the heuristic is compared against the pseudo-polynomial algorithm proposed by Ng et al. [2006]. In the second single machine interfering job sets problem (P2), the criteria of minimizing total weighted completion time and maximum lateness is studied. This is an established NP-hard problem for which a Forward WSPT-EDD heuristic is presented that attempts to generate set of supported points and the solution quality is compared with MIP formulations. For both of these problems, all jobs are available at time zero and the jobs are not allowed to be preempted.
ContributorsKhowala, Ketan (Author) / Fowler, John (Thesis advisor) / Keha, Ahmet (Thesis advisor) / Balasubramanian, Hari J (Committee member) / Wu, Teresa (Committee member) / Zhang, Muhong (Committee member) / Arizona State University (Publisher)
Created2012
Description
Assembly lines are low-cost production systems that manufacture similar finished units in large quantities. Manufacturers utilize mixed-model assembly lines to produce customized items that are not identical but share some general features in response to consumer needs. To maintain efficiency, the aim is to find the best feasible option to balance the lines efficiently; allocating each task to a workstation to satisfy all restrictions and fulfill all operational requirements in such a way that the line has the highest performance and maximum throughput. The work to be done at each workstation and line depends on the precise product configuration and is not constant across all models. This research seeks to enhance the subject of assembly line balancing by establishing a model for creating the most efficient assembly system. Several realistic characteristics are included into efficient optimization techniques and mathematical models to provide a more comprehensive model for building assembly systems. This involves analyzing the learning growth by task, employing parallel line designs, and configuring mixed models structure under particular constraints and criteria. This dissertation covers a gap in the literature by utilizing some exact and approximation modeling approaches. These methods are based on mathematical programming techniques, including integer and mixed integer models and heuristics. In this dissertation, heuristic approximations are employed to address problem-solving challenges caused by the problem's combinatorial complexity. This study proposes a model that considers learning curve effects and dynamic demand. This is exemplified in instances of a new assembly line, new employees, introducing new products or simply implementing engineering change orders. To achieve a cost-based optimal solution, an integer mathematical formulation is proposed to minimize the production line's total cost under the impact of learning and demand fulfillment. The research further creates approaches to obtain a comprehensive model in the case of single and mixed models for parallel lines systems. Optimization models and heuristics are developed under various aspects, such as cycle times by line and tooling considerations. Numerous extensions are explored effectively to analyze the cost impact under certain constraints and implications. The implementation results demonstrate that the proposed models and heuristics provide valuable insights.
ContributorsAlhomaidi, Esam (Author) / Askin, Ronald G (Thesis advisor) / Yan, Hao (Committee member) / Iquebal, Ashif (Committee member) / Sefair, Jorge (Committee member) / Arizona State University (Publisher)
Created2023