Matching Items (5)
Description
Hydrogen isotope compositions of the martian atmosphere and crustal materials can provide unique insights into the hydrological and geological evolution of Mars. While the present-day deuterium-to-hydrogen ratio (D/H) of the Mars atmosphere is well constrained (~6 times that of terrestrial ocean water), that of its deep silicate interior (specifically, the mantle) is less so. In fact, the hydrogen isotope composition of the primordial martian mantle is of great interest since it has implications for the origin and abundance of water on that planet. Martian meteorites could provide key constraints in this regard, since they crystallized from melts originating from the martian mantle and contain phases that potentially record the evolution of the H2O content and isotopic composition of the interior of the planet over time. Examined here are the hydrogen isotopic compositions of Nominally Anhydrous Phases (NAPs) in eight martian meteorites (five shergottites and three nakhlites) using Secondary Ion Mass Spectrometry (SIMS).
This study presents a total of 113 individual analyses of H2O contents and hydrogen isotopic compositions of NAPs in the shergottites Zagami, Los Angeles, QUE 94201, SaU 005, and Tissint, and the nakhlites Nakhla, Lafayette, and Yamato 000593. The hydrogen isotopic variation between and within meteorites may be due to one or more processes including: interaction with the martian atmosphere, magmatic degassing, subsolidus alteration (including shock), and/or terrestrial contamination. Taking into consideration the effects of these processes, the hydrogen isotope composition of the martian mantle may be similar to that of the Earth. Additionally, this study calculated upper limits on the H2O contents of the shergottite and nakhlite parent melts based on the measured minimum H2O abundances in their maskelynites and pyroxenes, respectively. These calculations, along with some petrogenetic assumptions based on previous studies, were subsequently used to infer the H2O contents of the mantle source reservoirs of the depleted shergottites (200-700 ppm) and the nakhlites (10-100 ppm). This suggests that mantle source of the nakhlites is systematically drier than that of the depleted shergottites, and the upper mantle of Mars may have preserved significant heterogeneity in its H2O content. Additionally, this range of H2O contents is not dissimilar to the range observed for the Earth’s upper mantle.
This study presents a total of 113 individual analyses of H2O contents and hydrogen isotopic compositions of NAPs in the shergottites Zagami, Los Angeles, QUE 94201, SaU 005, and Tissint, and the nakhlites Nakhla, Lafayette, and Yamato 000593. The hydrogen isotopic variation between and within meteorites may be due to one or more processes including: interaction with the martian atmosphere, magmatic degassing, subsolidus alteration (including shock), and/or terrestrial contamination. Taking into consideration the effects of these processes, the hydrogen isotope composition of the martian mantle may be similar to that of the Earth. Additionally, this study calculated upper limits on the H2O contents of the shergottite and nakhlite parent melts based on the measured minimum H2O abundances in their maskelynites and pyroxenes, respectively. These calculations, along with some petrogenetic assumptions based on previous studies, were subsequently used to infer the H2O contents of the mantle source reservoirs of the depleted shergottites (200-700 ppm) and the nakhlites (10-100 ppm). This suggests that mantle source of the nakhlites is systematically drier than that of the depleted shergottites, and the upper mantle of Mars may have preserved significant heterogeneity in its H2O content. Additionally, this range of H2O contents is not dissimilar to the range observed for the Earth’s upper mantle.
ContributorsTucker, Kera (Author) / Wadhwa, Meenakshi (Thesis advisor) / Hervig, Richard (Committee member) / Till, Christy (Committee member) / Arizona State University (Publisher)
Created2015
Description
Although nitrogen is the dominant element in Earth’s atmosphere, it is depleted in the bulk silicate Earth (relative to expected volatile abundances established by carbonaceous chondrites). To resolve this inconsistency, it has been hypothesized that this “missing nitrogen” may actually be stored within the Earth’s deep interior. In this work, we use multi-anvil press experiments to synthesize solid solution mixtures of the mantle transition zone mineral wadsleyite (Mg2SiO4) and silicon nitride (Si3N4). Successful synthesis of a 90% Si3N4, 10% Mg2SiO4 solid solution implies that nitrogen may not be sequestered within the most abundant mineral phases in the Earth’s mantle. Instead, nitrogen-rich accessory phases may hold the key to studying nitrogen storage within the deep interior. Ultimately, quantifying the amount of nitrogen within the mantle will further our understanding of the N cycle, which is vital to maintaining planetary habitability. Similar N cycling processes may be occurring on other rocky bodies; therefore, studying nitrogen storage may be an important part of determining habitability conditions on other worlds, both within in our solar system and beyond.
ContributorsRavikumar, Shradhanjli (Author) / Shim, Dan (Thesis director) / Sharp, Thomas (Committee member) / Hervig, Richard (Committee member) / Barrett, The Honors College (Contributor) / School of Earth and Space Exploration (Contributor)
Created2023-05
Description
The transport of hydrogen to the Earth’s deep interior remains uncertain. The upper mantle minerals have very low hydrogen solubilities (hundreds of ppm). The hydrogen storage capability in the transition zone minerals (2 wt%) is high compared to those of the upper mantle. The hydrogen storage in the lower mantle is not well known. The main minerals in the lower mantle bridgmanite and ferropericlase have very low hydrogen storage capacities (less than 20 ppm). In order to further understand the hydrogen storage in the lower mantle, a series of experiments had been conducted to simulate the environment similar to the Earth’s mantle. The experiments with hydrous Mg2SiO4 ringwoodite (Rw) show that it converts to crystalline dense hydrous silica, stishovite (Stv) or CaCl2-type SiO2(mStv), containing ∼1 wt% H2O together with bridgmanite (Brd) and MgO at the pressure-temperature conditions expected for lower mantle depths between approximately 660 to 1600 km. Brd would break down partially to dense hydrous silica (6–25 mol%) and(Mg,Fe)O in mid-mantle regions with 0.05–0.27 wt% H2O. The hydrous stishovite has a CaCl2 structure, which is common among hydrous minerals in the lower mantle. Based on this observation, I hypothesize the existence of hydrous phases in the lower mantle. The experiments found a new hexagonal iron hydroxide (η-Fe12O18+x/2Hx) between the stability fields of the epsilon and pyrite-type FeOOH at 60–80 GPa and high temperature. The new phase contains less H2O, limiting the H2O transport from the shallow to the deep mantle in the Fe–O–H system. Possible hydrogen storage in Ca-perovskite was studied. CaPv could contain 0.5–1 wt% water and the water in CaPv could distort the crystal structure of CaPv from cubic to tetragonal structure. In conclusion, hydrogen can be stored in hydrous stishovite in the shallower depth of the lower mantle. At greater depth, the new η phase and pyrite-type phase would take over the hydrogen storage. The role of CaPv in deep water storage needs to be considered in future studies.
ContributorsChen, Huawei (Author) / Shim, Sang-Heon (Thesis advisor) / Garnero, Edward (Committee member) / Bose, Maitrayee (Committee member) / Li, Mingming (Committee member) / Leinenweber, Kurt (Committee member) / Arizona State University (Publisher)
Created2019
Description
With the InSight mission deploying a seismometer , Martian bulk chemical compositional models are more important than ever. Three largely consistent models for the Martian mantle have been suggested over the past two decades. Of these three, two are fairly similar and one is dramatically different. Of these three, the EH70 (Sanloup et al., 1999) models have the systematically lower divalent cation to silicon ratios as compared to the other model, the DW85 (Dreibus and Wanke, 1985) model. However, impact of such a low (Mg+Fe+Ca)/Si ratio on mineralogy has not been experimentally investigated. Measurements have been made of the mineralogy of the EH70 bulk mantle composition (Sanloup et al., 1999)) through in-situ laser-heated diamond anvil cell (LHDAC) and large volume press (LVP). Majorite-garnet (Mj) dominated mineralogy has been observed up to 25 GPa. Bridgmanite (Bm) begins to appear from 25.2 GPa and continues in a mixed phase with Mj up to 27 GPa at which point only Bm and calcium perovskite (CaPv) remain. Akimotoite (Ak) is stable up to 1873 K, higher by ≈300 K compared to numerical calculations (Connolly, 2009). This may result in an Ak layer in the Martian mantle, something missing in Earth’s mantle. The overall ratio of pyroxene to olivine polymorphs by volume is high, approaching pure pyroxene. This agrees with numerical calculations. Additionally, ferropericlase (Fp) is stable at lower temperatures, suggesting a higher dependence on temperature for its stability, something that is different from Perple_X calculations which show a strong dependence on pressure. Furthermore, Mj, which make up a majority of the volume of EH70 mantles, was measured to increase in Fe content as pressure increases. The more oxidizing conditions coupled with the silicon-rich composition resulted in three times higher Fe3+ content in Mj as opposed to a pyrolite model. This increased Fe3+ meant our Mj composition approached that of skiagite (Ski,Fe2+ 3 Fe3+ 2 Si3O12) and this caused Mj to have a very low compressibility of only 152.8 GPa, lower than any other Mj compositions in literature. This result suggests that a mantle with EH70 bulk composition would have lower than predicted seismic wave velocities , lower than Perple_X predicts. The Al content of Mj was also found to suppress the first derivative of compressibility to 4.45, lower than that of Ski100 at 6.7. Such differences compared with pyrolitic composition are important to estimate the velocity profiles and to model the dynamics of the Martian mantle. This dataset of mineralogy and composition can also model terrestrial exoplanetary mantles. Current measurements of stellar abundances show a wide range of compositions, and especially compositions with (Mg+Fe+Ca)/Si ratios approaching 1 (Brewer and Fischer, 2016). This experimental study of EH70 composition can fill-in this gap.
ContributorsDolinschi, Jonathan David (Author) / Shim, Sang-Heon D. (Thesis advisor) / Desch, Steven (Committee member) / Lee, Mingming (Committee member) / Arizona State University (Publisher)
Created2019
Description
The redox conditions of Earth have been changing since proto-Earth’s accretion from the solar nebula. These changes have influenced the distribution and partitioning of volatile elements between the atmosphere and the mantle (Righter et al., 2020; Stagno and Fei, 2020. Though oxygen fugacity fO2 is arguably not the main factor for phase stability at certain pressure-temperature conditions (McCammon, 2005), it can influence which phases are stable, especially within a closed system such as the ones presented in this study. Despite the importance of controlling fO2 for interpreting the history of planetary bodies, there have been no methods to control the redox conditions in the laser-heated diamond anvil cell (LHDAC). This thesis has examined the feasibility for controlling redox conditions in the LHDAC using a mixture of Ar and H2 for insulation media. The experiments of this study were carried out at the GSECARS sector of the Advanced Photon Source at Argonne National Laboratory. In this study, α-Fe2O3 (hematite), ε-FeOOH (CaCl2-type), and Fe3O4 (magnetite) starting materials were used for probing changes of redox conditions. Experiments were also conducted with a pure Ar-medium for ε-FeOOH at the same pressure-temperature conditions of the hydrogen-bearing medium in order to provide a reference point for data which has uncontrolled redox conditions for an initially Fe(2+)-free material. The results for the ε-FeOOH starting material in Ar show transformation to ι-Fe2O3 (Rh2O3(II)-type) at 30.0 GPa and 1900 K, while in Ar + H2 it transformed to Fe5O7 with minor FeH (dhcp) at 30.0 GPa and 1850 K. For α-Fe2O3 in Ar + H2, it was found to convert to ε-FeOOH, Fe5O7, Fe5O6, and FeH (dhcp) at 36.5 GPa and 1800 K. For Fe3O4 in Ar + H2, it was found to convert to Fe4O5 (CaFe3O5-type), Fe5O6, and minor FeH (fcc) at 26.0 GPa and 1800 K. These results demonstrate that H in an Ar medium can promote the conversion of some Fe(3+) to Fe(2+) and Fe(0). However, the formation of ε-FeOOH in the α-Fe2O3 starting material suggests that H may participate in the chemical reaction of iron oxides.
ContributorsKulka, Britany Lynn (Author) / Shim, Sang-Heon (Thesis advisor) / Sharp, Thomas (Committee member) / Leinenweber, Kurt (Committee member) / Hervig, Richard (Committee member) / Arizona State University (Publisher)
Created2021